docs(batch): record BAT-057 draft verification evidence

docs/batches/bat-057_20260714_operator-broker-truth-hotfix/index.md

@@ -30,4 +30,4 @@
 ## Notes
 - Cross-service contract, security, migration 또는 scope trade-off가 발견되면 구현을 진행하지 않고 lead gate로 중단한다.
 - 모든 evidence는 credential, token, app key/secret, raw account number/payload를 포함하지 않는 masked label/fingerprint만 사용한다.
-- 다음 gate는 design이며, implementation은 feature worktree/PR와 independent QC를 거쳐야 한다.
+- 다음 gate는 PR #42 (`feat/dcy-037-operator-broker-truth-hotfix`)의 independent QC이며, batch verification은 draft/in-delivery 상태로 유지한다. QC 전에는 `confirm-batch-verification`, REQ Implemented 또는 release readiness를 주장하지 않는다.

docs/batches/bat-057_20260714_operator-broker-truth-hotfix/verification.md

@@ -2,23 +2,39 @@
 
 - Status: draft
 - Batch: BAT-057
+- Delivery ref: PR #42 — `feat/dcy-037-operator-broker-truth-hotfix` (committed PR head at evidence drafting)
+- Scope of this artifact: implementation-lane draft evidence only. This is not `confirm-batch-verification`, does not mark any REQ Implemented, and makes no Release Ready claim.
+
+## Evidence Boundary
+
+- No live broker, PostgreSQL database, deployment, production target, credential, or `sync --live` execution was performed.
+- The focused suite used an in-process `pika` stub. Its recorded result is **68 passed, 1 skipped, 1 deselected**.
+- `compileall`, changed-file `ruff`, `git diff --check`, and the documentation secret scan passed.
+- The subprocess case `test_config_required_cli_exits_nonzero` remains blocked solely because `pika` is absent in the isolated worktree subprocess. The subprocess cannot inherit the in-process stub. This is an environment/dependency-setup blocker, not a recorded behavioral failure.
 
 ## Acceptance Mapping
-- REQ-119: fetched source parity, no-silent-fallback, env-only regression, safe identity/redaction evidence.
-- REQ-120: failure-class vs true-empty separation, non-zero/no-write semantics, lifecycle/throttle behavior, secret-safe artifacts.
-- REQ-121: four-case reconciliation matrix, PostgreSQL/InMemory parity, instance isolation, no-auto-remediation.
-- REQ-122: runtime/interface/operations documentation cross-check against implementation evidence and CLI/help/decision-code reality.
 
-## Evidence
+| REQ / acceptance coverage | Draft implementation evidence | Remaining verification boundary |
-- Test:
+| --- | --- | --- |
-  - To be collected after implementation; independent QC re-execution required.
+| REQ-119 — fetched provider parity, no silent fallback, break-glass/env-only compatibility, safe source identity | Focused provider/CLI regression coverage passed under the in-process `pika` stub; changed-file lint/diff and secret scan passed. | Independent QC must rerun the PR #42 evidence and assess the blocked subprocess case in an environment with `pika` available. No live broker evidence exists. |
-- Manual:
+| REQ-120 — fail-loud balance failures, nonzero/no-write barrier, true-empty separation, lifecycle/redaction | Focused adapter and CLI failure-path regression coverage passed under the stub; secret scan passed. | Independent QC must rerun failure/no-write and true-empty evidence. The unavailable subprocess prevents a complete isolated CLI-process confirmation. |
-  - Release-gated dry-run evidence only; no live sync authorized in this batch handoff.
+| REQ-121 — four-case divergence classification, instance isolation, no auto-remediation, repository parity | Focused reconciliation and InMemory-oriented regression coverage passed under the stub. | **Environmental coverage gap:** no live/local PostgreSQL fixture was executed, so PostgreSQL/InMemory parity is not claimed. Independent QC must retain this gap or obtain an approved non-production PostgreSQL fixture. No live broker or database was used. |
-- Logs:
+| REQ-122 — runtime/interface/operations alignment, safe examples, release-gated remediation | Baseline documentation changes at the PR #42 tip were included in changed-file diff checks; documentation secret scan passed. | Independent QC must cross-check the rendered baseline text, actual CLI/help and decision-code behavior against the committed PR diff. This artifact does not authorize a production command or deployment. |
-  - Masked source labels/fingerprints and sanitized codes only; no credential/token/account disclosure.
 
-## Result
+## Draft Validation Results
-- Ready for Release: false
+
-- Blocking Issues:
+| Check | Result | Notes |
-  - Design, implementation and independent QC are not complete.
+| --- | --- | --- |
-  - `sync --live` requires separate release approval and is not authorized.
+| Focused suite | PASS — 68 passed, 1 skipped, 1 deselected | In-process `pika` stub used. |
+| `compileall` | PASS | Recorded implementation-lane validation. |
+| Changed-file `ruff` | PASS | Recorded implementation-lane validation. |
+| `git diff --check` | PASS | Recorded implementation-lane validation. |
+| Documentation secret scan | PASS | No credentials, tokens, raw account numbers, or raw credential payloads in scanned documentation. |
+| `test_config_required_cli_exits_nonzero` subprocess | BLOCKED (environment) | Isolated worktree lacks `pika`; subprocess cannot inherit the in-process stub. |
+| PostgreSQL repository parity/live database coverage | NOT EXECUTED (environmental coverage gap) | Do not infer PostgreSQL parity from InMemory-focused evidence. |
+
+## Result and Next Gate
+
+- Draft evidence is recorded for PR #42 only; the batch remains **in-delivery** and this verification artifact remains **draft**.
+- Independent QC is pending. It must review the exact PR #42 ref, rerun the focused evidence independently, and explicitly disposition the isolated-subprocess `pika` blocker and PostgreSQL environmental coverage gap.
+- `sync --live`, live broker/database access, deployment, and production remediation remain outside this artifact and require their separate release approval gate.